3. Councils' acquisition of one's IP address when visiting their websites.
« previous next »
Pages: [1] 2

Author Topic: Councils' acquisition of one's IP address when visiting their websites.  (Read 4536 times)

0 Members and 206 Guests are viewing this topic.

Councils' acquisition of one's IP address when visiting their websites.
« on: »
This concerns me. And I suggest that all recipients of PCNs note this when they do so. And make a FOIR. One council (Lewisham) has even alleged that I had not viewed a client's case at all on its website.
« Last Edit: September 20, 2025, 07:03:56 pm by Hippocrates »
Logged
IF YOU RECEIVE A MOVING TRAFFIC PCN PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE MAKING A REPRESENTATION:

https://www.ftla.uk/the-flame-pit/moving-traffic-pcns-missing-mandatory-information-the-london-local-authorities-a/msg102639/#msg102639


How do we get more people to fight their PCNs?

https://www.ftla.uk/the-flame-pit/how-do-we-get-more-people-to-fight-their-pcns/msg41917/#msg41917

If you do not even make a challenge, you will surely join "The Mugged Club".

I am not omniscient. cp8759 and mrmustard are true geniuses. I know my place in the hierarchy of The Three Musketeers. 😊 "The Clinician", "The Gentleman" and "The Showman"

My e mail address for councils:

J.BOND007@H.M.S.S.c/oVAUXHALLBRIDGE/LICENSEDTOEXPOSE.SCAMS.CO.UK

Last mission accomplished:

https://www.ftla.uk/the-flame-pit/southwark-to-r

Share on Bluesky Share on Facebook

Like Like x 1 Dislike Dislike x 1 View List
Re: Councils' acquisition of one's IP address when visiting their websites.
« Reply #1 on: »
With my Computing lecturer hat on, I see no cause for concern. An IP address does not identify an individual (both factually and legally, according to case law from file sharing cases). Unless you've specifically paid for a fixed one and never use a mobile device or a different wifi network, they can change arbitrarily.
Logged
Like Like x 1 View List
Re: Councils' acquisition of one's IP address when visiting their websites.
« Reply #2 on: »
You'd probably go a long way to find a website around that doesn't record one's IP address these days.
Logged
Like Like x 1 View List
Re: Councils' acquisition of one's IP address when visiting their websites.
« Reply #3 on: »
There is literally no way for a website to send you a page without temporarily storing your IP address, so it's actually just a question of how long that information is retained.
Logged
Re: Councils' acquisition of one's IP address when visiting their websites.
« Reply #4 on: »
@Stedman What is it you dislike about my initial post? I am taking the point that, if a council makes a statement that I have not visited their website re a particular case, this should surely be challenged when I have.

Please post a reply.
« Last Edit: September 23, 2025, 12:06:54 pm by Hippocrates »
Logged
IF YOU RECEIVE A MOVING TRAFFIC PCN PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE MAKING A REPRESENTATION:

https://www.ftla.uk/the-flame-pit/moving-traffic-pcns-missing-mandatory-information-the-london-local-authorities-a/msg102639/#msg102639


How do we get more people to fight their PCNs?

https://www.ftla.uk/the-flame-pit/how-do-we-get-more-people-to-fight-their-pcns/msg41917/#msg41917

If you do not even make a challenge, you will surely join "The Mugged Club".

I am not omniscient. cp8759 and mrmustard are true geniuses. I know my place in the hierarchy of The Three Musketeers. 😊 "The Clinician", "The Gentleman" and "The Showman"

My e mail address for councils:

J.BOND007@H.M.S.S.c/oVAUXHALLBRIDGE/LICENSEDTOEXPOSE.SCAMS.CO.UK

Last mission accomplished:

https://www.ftla.uk/the-flame-pit/southwark-to-r
Re: Councils' acquisition of one's IP address when visiting their websites.
« Reply #5 on: »
OK, if you want a reply then I will reply.

What I don't like about your post is your level of paranoia. As Grant Urismo and DWMB2 have already, it's standard practice for virtually all websites - probably even this one.
Logged
Re: Councils' acquisition of one's IP address when visiting their websites.
« Reply #6 on: »
Quote
I am taking the point that, if a council makes a statement that I have not visited their website re a particular case, this should surely be challenged when I have.
Was their stated reasoning for this based solely on IP addresses?

If so, that would seem to be a rather flawed use of IP address logs, regardless of any broader views as to their storage of the same in the first place.
Logged
Like Like x 1 Agree Agree x 1 View List
Re: Councils' acquisition of one's IP address when visiting their websites.
« Reply #7 on: »
Surely just by recording your IP address doesn't mean you were the person accessing it. Much like because you're the RK of a car doesn't mean you were driving it.
Logged
Bus driving since 1973. My advice, if you have a PSV licence, destroy it when you get to 65 or you'll be forever in demand.
Like Like x 1 Agree Agree x 1 View List
Re: Councils' acquisition of one's IP address when visiting their websites.
« Reply #8 on: »
Quote from: Stedman on September 23, 2025, 12:16:24 pm
OK, if you want a reply then I will reply.

What I don't like about your post is your level of paranoia. As Grant Urismo and DWMB2 have already, it's standard practice for virtually all websites - probably even this one.

I am not paranoid. Rather, pragmatic. Cada loco con su tema.
Logged
IF YOU RECEIVE A MOVING TRAFFIC PCN PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE MAKING A REPRESENTATION:

https://www.ftla.uk/the-flame-pit/moving-traffic-pcns-missing-mandatory-information-the-london-local-authorities-a/msg102639/#msg102639


How do we get more people to fight their PCNs?

https://www.ftla.uk/the-flame-pit/how-do-we-get-more-people-to-fight-their-pcns/msg41917/#msg41917

If you do not even make a challenge, you will surely join "The Mugged Club".

I am not omniscient. cp8759 and mrmustard are true geniuses. I know my place in the hierarchy of The Three Musketeers. 😊 "The Clinician", "The Gentleman" and "The Showman"

My e mail address for councils:

J.BOND007@H.M.S.S.c/oVAUXHALLBRIDGE/LICENSEDTOEXPOSE.SCAMS.CO.UK

Last mission accomplished:

https://www.ftla.uk/the-flame-pit/southwark-to-r
Agree Agree x 2 View List
Re: Councils' acquisition of one's IP address when visiting their websites.
« Reply #9 on: »
Quote from: DWMB2 on September 23, 2025, 01:54:37 pm
Quote
I am taking the point that, if a council makes a statement that I have not visited their website re a particular case, this should surely be challenged when I have.
Was their stated reasoning for this based solely on IP addresses?

If so, that would seem to be a rather flawed use of IP address logs, regardless of any broader views as to their storage of the same in the first place.
Yet to  be divulged via a formal complaint. They bluntly stated in their evidence pack that I had not accessed their website to view the case when I had.
« Last Edit: September 23, 2025, 07:53:21 pm by Hippocrates »
Logged
IF YOU RECEIVE A MOVING TRAFFIC PCN PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE MAKING A REPRESENTATION:

https://www.ftla.uk/the-flame-pit/moving-traffic-pcns-missing-mandatory-information-the-london-local-authorities-a/msg102639/#msg102639


How do we get more people to fight their PCNs?

https://www.ftla.uk/the-flame-pit/how-do-we-get-more-people-to-fight-their-pcns/msg41917/#msg41917

If you do not even make a challenge, you will surely join "The Mugged Club".

I am not omniscient. cp8759 and mrmustard are true geniuses. I know my place in the hierarchy of The Three Musketeers. 😊 "The Clinician", "The Gentleman" and "The Showman"

My e mail address for councils:

J.BOND007@H.M.S.S.c/oVAUXHALLBRIDGE/LICENSEDTOEXPOSE.SCAMS.CO.UK

Last mission accomplished:

https://www.ftla.uk/the-flame-pit/southwark-to-r
Re: Councils' acquisition of one's IP address when visiting their websites.
« Reply #10 on: »
Again with my Computing lecturer hat on, paranoia and a desire to learn through asking questions are highly desirable traits in a cybersecurity student, so I felt the need to balance out the likes on Hippocrates original question.

This stuff isn't obvious or simple, so I am happy to deliver as much of a lecture on TCP/IP as the regulars would like in order to help them argue points in front of adjudicators from a position of knowledge.
Logged
Re: Councils' acquisition of one's IP address when visiting their websites.
« Reply #11 on: »
Although the points made about IP address "collection" being both technically unavoidable and incapable of identifying an individual are valid, isn't it nevertheless blindingly obvious that there are circumstances where information about IP addresses which have accessed a website could still provide an organisation with evidence about whether or not a particular individual has accessed it? 

After all, if nobody at all has accessed the website, that would logically prove that no specific individual has accessed it.

Alternatively, if the only people to access the website are people from within the organisation's own IP range, that would show that no individual outside the organisation has accessed it.

Logged
Re: Councils' acquisition of one's IP address when visiting their websites.
« Reply #12 on: »
Quote from: Grant Urismo on September 22, 2025, 05:30:02 pm
With my Computing lecturer hat on, I see no cause for concern. An IP address does not identify an individual (both factually and legally, according to case law from file sharing cases). Unless you've specifically paid for a fixed one and never use a mobile device or a different wifi network, they can change arbitrarily.

Although you are of course correct that an IP address doesn't identify an individual, on its own, it is regarded as an "online identifier" under GDPR, and "online identifiers" do legally constitute personal data. 

An IP address, combined with other information, can after all be used to distinguish one person from another, and thus to identify an individual.

After all, if you think about it, a name doesn't identify an individual.   There are thousands of John Smiths, to take the usual example.  But combine the name with an address, or a telephone number, or height, or birthdate, and you can tell one from John Smith from another and thus identify an individual.

The point being that "personal data" isn't necessarily data that identifies a person on its own.
Logged
Re: Councils' acquisition of one's IP address when visiting their websites.
« Reply #13 on: »
Interestingly though, this largely will depend on the infrastructure their website (or PCN "portal") is hosted on.

For instance, when the old PPP domain was going to expire, I had built a "reverse proxy" site so that it could still be accessed. The very nature of this meant that the PPP forum software only saw my reverse proxy's address and not the end users (this was never needed as they renewed the domain then killed the forum... oh well)

If the portal is hosted behind a reverse proxy, and that reverse proxy or the portal software is misconfigured, then the portal may never see any other IP addresses other than it's own infrastructure, hence the "You've not looked at it".

Not to mention that most mobile data comes out on a limited range of IP addresses (ever had the "You've already viewed 3 articles today" on newspaper sites on mobile data?).

In the short term, I guess that it is prudent that you print to pdf a copy of the portal site so you can contradict their statements in future?
Logged
Re: Councils' acquisition of one's IP address when visiting their websites.
« Reply #14 on: »
I suppose if anything is going to be misconfigured, it's a council website.
Logged
Like Like x 1 View List
Pages: [1] 2
« previous next »
  3. Councils' acquisition of one's IP address when visiting their websites.