Author Topic: Euro Parking Services - County Court Claim  (Read 2581 times)

0 Members and 55 Guests are viewing this topic.

Re: Euro Car Parks County Court Claim
« Reply #15 on: »
Gladstones in this case.
Agree Agree x 1 View List

Re: Euro Parking Services - County Court Claim
« Reply #16 on: »
A mediation appointment is now booked for mid-March. I can see the advice on the other thread is just to offer £0 and the call will end quickly. It does state “You will need to briefly explain your claim or defence to the mediator. You should prepare for yourself a brief summary of the main points”. Should I just read out the wording from the original alledged PCN?

Re: Euro Parking Services - County Court Claim
« Reply #17 on: »
You can say what you like, it’s not really relevant, I’d simply say that I’m not prepared to settle and that will be that. The people running the mediation process will tick their boxes. It has no influence or relevance to the case.

You don’t have to explain anything to the mediator.
Agree Agree x 2 View List

Re: Euro Parking Services - County Court Claim
« Reply #18 on: »
If asked about your defence you can say that the claimant has received a written copy, you stand by the points you have made in it and accordingly are not looking to debate the merits of your case here.

Re: Euro Parking Services - County Court Claim
« Reply #19 on: »
This has not gone away and I’ve just found out that they are progressing to a court hearing on 9th July 2025 in the county court. Letters were being sent to my old address which I no longer live at, however, Gladstones have emailed me a trial bundle ahead of the hearing. I now live in Northern Ireland so it is not possible for me to attend the hearing in Manchester. Previously I joined the mediation call and as advised I fid not agree to any settlement figure. Is there any advice at this stage? I wasn’t expecting them to proceed to a court hearing

Re: Euro Car Parks County Court Claim
« Reply #20 on: »
On 27th January you were advised as follows:

Updating your V5C now will not stop further letters about this going to the old address. The only way you can change the address for service is to complete the Acknowledgement of Service (AoS) with the correct address for service.

However you MUST also send a Data Rectification Notice (DRN) to the DPO's of both ECP and DCB Legal. The DRN must instruct them to update their records with your current address for service and to erase your old address. The highlighted words are there for a reason and you must use them.

Did you take that advice and follow it??? Since when have you resided in NI? That is a critical point that we needed to know about.

Was the Claim sent to your old address in England and you were by then resident in NI? What address is on the Claim Form, your English or NI address?

Why have you only just now found out that there is a hearing on 7th July, 5 days away??? If you'd correctly updated your address as advised, all correspondence would have been sent to your NI address!

Before I can offer any further advice, please confirm to which address was the Claim Served? English or NI address?

If you want advice, then @ps25, you need to answer this urgently!
« Last Edit: July 02, 2025, 11:59:23 am by b789 »
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience” - Mark Twain

Re: Euro Parking Services - County Court Claim
« Reply #21 on: »
Yes I did that the next day on 28th January. I sent a DRN to both Gladstones and Euro Car Parks. I have the emails. Gladstones data protection emailed me back on 6th Feb with a letter to state that they have updated my address, but would not erase the data. The hearing is on 9th July. I only found out about this a few days ago when Gladstones emailed me a trial pack. The AoS has my Manchester address on (which was correct at the time) but 2 months later I moved to Northern Ireland. I sent an email to the court this morning (7 days prior to the hearing) that I have moved to NI and wouldn’t be able to attend the hearing in person and if I could attend via video link

Re: Euro Parking Services - County Court Claim
« Reply #22 on: »
The claim form was sent to my Manchester address and is dated 15th Jan when I still lived there. The AoS on 28th Jan also has my Manchester address. I emailed a DRN to both Gladstones and Euro Car Parks on 28th Jan to provide my NI address. The trial pack I have now been emailed has a Notice of Transfer of Proceedings dated 26th March and stamped 8th April stating that the claim has been transferred to the county court in Manchester. This is the first I have seen this. There is also a Notice of Allocation to the Small Claims Track (Hearing) dated 17th May. I was emailed the Claimants Witness statement from Gladstones on 25th June. This is written by a Rashpal Chana from Birmingham, an employee of the Claimant’s company

Re: Euro Parking Services - County Court Claim
« Reply #23 on: »
You received the claimants WS bundle a week ago!!! What are we only finding out about this today?

Once you were aware of ongoing proceedings, you were obliged to inform the court (CNBC if before allocation to Manchester or Manchester if it had already been allocated).

Under CPR 5.4C and general court practice, parties have a duty to keep the court informed of their current address once proceedings are live. The initial obligation to serve documents correctly lies with the claimant. Once the defendant acknowledges service (AoS) or files a defence, they are expected to update the court if their address changes.

The AoS was filed on 28 Jan with the Manchester address. You moved to Northern Ireland shortly after and notified Gladstones and the claimant on the same day (28 Jan) via a Data Rectification Notice. Gladstones acknowledged the new address on 6 Feb.

But you did not notify the court directly. While the claimant was informed, the court was not—so the court continued to send documents (e.g. allocation order, hearing notice) to the Manchester address.

The court will likely say “You should have told us”. However, you can argue that the claimant knew the new address and should have ensured the court was updated. You only discovered the hearing date when the trial bundle was emailed on 25 June. This late notice has prejudiced your ability to prepare and attend.

Even though the transfer was automatic and procedurally correct at the time, the situation changed. You never received the allocation order or hearing notice—only discovering it 5 days before the hearing via the claimant’s bundle. This creates a procedural unfairness, even if the original transfer was valid.

I don't know what you emailed to the court but I suggest you follow it up with the following:

Quote
Subject: URGENT – Objection to Hearing Proceeding – Case No [INSERT] – Hearing 7 July 2024
To: [Insert Manchester County Court email address]

Dear Sir/Madam,

I write urgently regarding the above matter, listed for hearing on 7 July 2024 at Manchester County Court.

I object to the hearing proceeding at all, on the following grounds:

• I did not receive the Notice of Allocation, hearing date, or any directions from the court.
• I only became aware of the hearing on 25 June 2024, when the claimant’s legal representative (Gladstones Solicitors) emailed me their trial bundle. This was the first time I saw the allocation order or the hearing date.
• I relocated to Northern Ireland in early February 2024 and notified both the claimant and Gladstones of my new address on 28 January 2024 via a Data Rectification Notice. Gladstones acknowledged this on 6 February 2024.
• The court was not updated with my new address, and as a result, I have been denied proper notice of the hearing and any opportunity to comply with directions.

This is a clear breach of CPR 27.4 and CPR 1.1, and it undermines my right to a fair hearing under Article 6 ECHR.

I therefore request that the hearing be vacated immediately and relisted only after proper notice and directions have been served to my current address.

If the court intends to proceed regardless, I request urgent confirmation and reasons, so I may consider further action.

Yours faithfully,

[Full Name]

[Case Number]
[NI Address]
[Email Address]
[Phone Number]
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience” - Mark Twain

Re: Euro Parking Services - County Court Claim
« Reply #24 on: »
Thanks I have emailed this to the court. If they don't respond is there any way I can attend the hearing via telephone or video link?

Re: Euro Parking Services - County Court Claim
« Reply #25 on: »
Thanks I have emailed this to the court. If they don't respond is there any way I can attend the hearing via telephone or video link?

Not unless the court approves it. However, there is a serious jurisdictional issue with the claim and if everything had been done correctly, the clam would have been struck out at allocation once your NI address was known.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience” - Mark Twain

Re: Euro Parking Services - County Court Claim
« Reply #26 on: »
I haven’t heard back from the court yet but did receive this email from someone acting for the claimant asking if I want to settle. Would there be a chance they will pull out of this prior to Wednesday 9th’s court hearing? I’d be reluctant to settle

[ Guests cannot view attachments ]

Re: Euro Parking Services - County Court Claim
« Reply #27 on: »
Phone the court now and find out what happened today. Whether the email you sent was received, whether the hearing was vacated or what!

That email is a “Without Prejudice Save as to Costs” settlement overture from Euro Parking Services, sent just days before the hearing. This means the offer can’t be shown to the judge during the hearing on liability, but can be shown later if there’s a dispute about costs—e.g. if they win and argue you acted unreasonably by refusing to settle.

They’re nervous. This kind of last-minute settlement offer suggests they know their case is shaky—or that your procedural objections could derail the hearing. (assuming they are aware of the jurisdiction issue). They’re trying to avoid the risk of adjournment, strike-out, or costs.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience” - Mark Twain

Re: Euro Parking Services - County Court Claim
« Reply #28 on: »
Reply #19 has the court date for Wednesday 9 July. But phone the court as a matter of urgency to find out what’s planned, for sure.

Re: Euro Parking Services - County Court Claim
« Reply #29 on: »
On the phone with the court. The hearing is still set for 9th (Wed). He is advising to fill out a N244 form for a judge to review. Is this correct?