Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - settop23

Pages: [1] 2 3 4
1
I did mention to the claimants side before we went in that I had to take the afternoon off work to attend (and pay an outrageous £12 to park for a couple of hours!)

Nothing was mentioned about a counterclaim or claiming for loss of earnings to attend.  I am self employed so what proof would I need to provide to claim?

2
I attended the hearing and arrived 30 mins early. The claimants representative was already there, it seemed to be somebody qualified and not the paralegal 'under supervision' from BW Legal.

We went into the court and the judge listened to the claimants argument first.  The judge asked the claimant about the signage and where the signage was in relation to where the vehicle was parked - the claimant struggled to provide an answer and eventually admitted she did not have that information with her, only a seperate picture of the signage and pictures of my vehicle.

The judge then turned to me and told me 'Good news, as the claimant cannot prove their case it is dismissed!'

A great result and a huge thank you to DWMB2, Intercity and andy_foster for all the help - I certainly would not have been able to do it without you and I have learnt some things as opposed to blindly paying hundreds of pounds to line the pockets of chancers.

3
The case is listed for tommorow. Thank you for the advice so far, and I plan on taking 3 copies of everything, the claimants WS and evidence along with the VCS Ltd V Edward case.

As advised, I will mainly try to argue point 14 in my skeleton argument:  that the signage at the location is prohibitive in nature and does not form a contract as there was no offer of valuable consideration.

Any other pointers and tips would be appreciated as it is my first time attending court to defend a claim.  If the other party does not turn up, will the case still be looked at or will I automatically win?

4
I have sent the PDF to the above emails today. I did not include any extra points as I think the points included already are sufficient

Should I take both my skeletoon argument and the evidence from the claimant with me to court?  Is there any other advice as it is the first time I am attending court

5


I have amended the WS and included the points from Intercity, thank you again.

in your opinion DWMB2 and Andy, should I add anything about Mazur or anything else or is this okay to submit?

I believe I need to save it as a PDF and email it to manchestercivil@justice.gov.uk and include the date & time of hearing and case number in the email? Do I need to include anything else. I will also send it to info@cpmsmanchester.com

6
Thank you so much! I will amend it and the prohibitive signage now makes much more sense to me after your explanation Andy, so I am confident I will be able
To expand on this argument in court if needed

I will amend my WS and change it to a skeleton argument and submit it today. Is it sufficient to send it as a PDF via email to the court and the claimant, and include the case number in the subject?

The only point not included in the skeleton argument  is that the claimant is using an unauthorised person as demonstrated in mazur. Is this a point you recommend I leave out for now and raise it at court? Will I have the option to do this if it is not in the skeleton argument?

7
Thank you all for this valuable insight and taking the time to look through the evidence.

I have prepared a draft copy of this witness statement. I have not provided one before, please let me know if it is okay. 

There are 3 pictures of the vehicle provided in the evidence, and the timetstamp is at the bottom left in yellow. They are difficult to see but i believe 2 of them show the vehicle parked at 14:40 and the other at 14:41. 

 Do I email the WS to the court and to the claimants email?


https://ibb.co/G4ZHQKF9
https://ibb.co/VcqqVC98
https://ibb.co/Kc4mVzSs

8
Hello

Any advice regarding this? If i have messed up by not submitted WS, is there any point in attending court, or can I arrange to pay the balance on a monthly basis?

9
Hello

Thank you for the help, and I must apologise the defence I submitted was done in a rush and taken from another case I posted. I hope it does not affect my chances.

I have also just checked through the documents and the papers i receieved from the court on 05 February state witness statements must be submitted by 05 march

I have uploaded the evidence :

https://ibb.co/JjwsCFX4
https://ibb.co/qLJ77tKx
https://ibb.co/YTcDPXKG
https://ibb.co/C39KRyqM
https://ibb.co/fVB7PktL
https://ibb.co/S77xW79V
https://ibb.co/C30K585h
https://ibb.co/W4Rw87vP
https://ibb.co/yc4ZSdYn
https://ibb.co/3mvd0hmS
https://ibb.co/1Yp9SxrL
https://ibb.co/s9pWSvZm
https://ibb.co/W42vSHDq
https://ibb.co/9ky7pkF9
https://ibb.co/wNkw4q1t
https://ibb.co/sdPbH0FJ
https://ibb.co/Wv68GFRq
https://ibb.co/0RsSkP16

If you guys think I have a good chance of winning this at court, please do advise the best way to proceed

10
Thanks for the reply.

I do not have the original NTK, and have not appealed or engaged with the company in any way - except from the AoS and defence submitted on Mcol.

I have enclosed the evidence which they have sent in a pack, i believe it includes the original Ntk. There is also a skeleton argument and a witness statement from a paralegal at BW.

https://ibb.co/qFm4LFPm
https://ibb.co/vvgcL21n
https://ibb.co/rjgQd3j
https://ibb.co/YTBCWbDw

11
Hello

I receieved a claim form on in May 2025, and submitted an AOS and defence in July.  By December 2025, the claim was transferred to my local court as per the DQ.

Please find here the claim form : https://ibb.co/1GppqjKK

The defence I submitted is at the bottom of this message.  Unfortunately I don't believe I seeked legal advice on here for this specific case and filed a defence which I had previously used for a similar case.

the case is now listed for a hearing at the end of this month. BW legal have sent their defence to my defence accross this week, and it mainly states that interest is not charged and quotes the signage that they rely upon which states no parking at any time.

I am the RK of the vehicle. The date of the parking is December 2024.  I believe the driver of the vehicle parked there only for a short time (less than 5 minutes) and once they realised they did not have permission to park there they moved the car.

Any help with this would be appreciated







1. The Defendant denies any liability for this claim.

2. There is a lack of precise detail in the Particulars of Claim
(PoC) in respect of the factual and legal allegations made against
the Defendant such that the PoC do not comply with CPR 16.4.

3. The Defendant is unable to plead properly to the PoC because:
(a) The contract referred to is not detailed or attached to the
PoC in accordance with CPR PD 16(7.5);

(b) The PoC do not state the exact wording of the clause (or
clauses) of the terms and conditions of the contract (or
contracts) which is/are relied on;

(c) The PoC do not state with sufficient particularity the exact
time when the breaches occurred and how long it is alleged that
the vehicle was parked before the parking charges were allegedly
incurred;

(e) The PoC do not state exactly how the claim for statutory
interest is calculated;

(f) The PoC do not state what proportion of the claim are the
parking charges and what proportion is damages;

(g) The PoC states that the Claimant is suing the defendant as the
driver or the keeper. The claimant obviously knows whether the
defendant is being sued as the driver or the keeper and should not
be permitted to plead alternative causes of action.

4. The Defendant has attached to this defence a copy of an order
made at another court which the allocating judge ought to make at
this stage so that the Defendant can then know and understand the
case which he/she/it faces and can then respond properly to the
claim.

Statement of truth

I believe that the facts stated in this Defence are true. I
understand that proceedings for contempt of court may be brought
against anyone who makes, or causes to be made, a false statement
in a document verified by a statement of truth without an honest
belief in its truth.






12
https://imgpile.com/p/XjGmaKf#wKiYon7

I think I am just going to send the requested information to them via the email on the letter this weekend.

On a side note, I was operating on Uber and the job time shows 10:16 for some reason, however the PCN was at 10:09am.  I think the uber job shows the time I completed the job or something.

13
Hello

I filed an appeal for this PCN online, stating that I was a private hire driver picking up a passenger.  They have replied via post and asked for a job sheet or invoice which confirms I was carrying a passenger. They have said that I need to send this information via return post in 14 days.

My question is why do I have to send it via post? This will incur charges that I do not wish to pay for.  Can I email the requested information to them instead?

14
Indeed, that seems like the most likely explanation. I have been PCN'd here before but it was a while ago, and I remember driving down it recently and not reeceiving the PCN.

Is it best to pay it at the discounted rate now, or is there any way out of it??

15
Yes, it seems on double red lines you can pick up and drop off passengers but cannot wait. As i was picking up a passenger that was waiting there, is it worth appealing on these grounds?

Pages: [1] 2 3 4