Author Topic: Ealing, Contravention 25 - Parked in a loading bay during restricted hours, Ruislip Road East (GRE) op Leyland  (Read 230 times)

0 Members and 61 Guests are viewing this topic.

Hello there,

I received a PCN for parking in a loading bay in the evening. I was picking up my mother as she was visiting her friend in a nearby apartment (area is notorious for limited parking). She has arthritis and finds it difficult walking short distances. She does possess a blue badge, but I did not have it on me at the time.

This is the link to PCN.

For reference, this is the Google Street View link.

Is there a case for appeal? Would appreciate any sort of advice on this matter.

Thank you
« Last Edit: February 02, 2026, 11:31:23 am by AshNaz87 »

Share on Bluesky Share on Facebook


From your narrative I think you are entitled to the "assisted boarding" exemption. Can you please outline what you did on arriving with your car through to your mother being in the car ready for you to drive off.

Hey @Incandescent,

I did check for street parking, but there were no bays available. The only other place I could have parked in was at a supermarket, but 1) it's further away and 2) I wouldn't be a customer. I hope I understood your question right

You misunderstood. At the moment I am assuming you parked the car, then left it to go to where your mother was staying, and assist her to your car. This is called "assisted boarding". Normal boarding is where the passenger can wait or come to the roadside unassisted to board the car. I just wanted you to tell us what you did between parking the car and driving away with your mother on-board. Boarding/alighting passengers is an exemption to most restrictions like yellow lines. 

Sorry, thanks for clarifying. That is correct. Apart from perhaps providing a copy of my mother's blue badge and explaining the situation, is there anything else that may help my case?

How long dod it take - if you were in and out with your mother then you have a shot at assisted boarding. You need a convincing account as to why she shouldn't wait at the kerbside.

About 10 minutes, as she walks slower than your average person. The CEO only observed the car for 3 mins

You don't want to volunteer a time, only as long as necessary and necessarily a bit longer than the observation time, and you have the BB as evidence.

But 10 mins as in this case can be seen as reasonable by an adju
-----------



Case reference 2250464004
Appellant Maimuna Jallow
Authority London Borough of Tower Hamlets
VRM GP24HFK
PCN Details
PCN TT59171456
Contravention date 18 May 2025
Contravention time 11:57:10
Contravention location Commercial Street
Penalty amount GBP 160.00
Contravention Parked resident/shared use without a valid permit
Referral date -
Decision Date 02 Feb 2026
Adjudicator Sean Stanton-Dunne
Appeal decision Appeal allowed
Direction
cancel the Penalty Charge Notice and the Notice to Owner.

Reasons
Mr Edrissa Cham has attended the hearing today as the authorised representative of the appellant.

Mr Cham says that he was collecting his 94 year old grandma and that, upon arrival, she was experiencing chest pains and acute breathlessness. He says that he placed her down in the correct position and provided her with inhalers until she eventually stabilised. Mr Cham says that the whole incident was less than 10 minutes and that he walked his grandma to the car with his brother when she was recovered.

The picking up exemption allows for a motorist to leave a vehicle where a passenger requires assistance. It is more likely than not to be the case that a 94 year old may need some assistance when being picked up.

I am satisfied that the purpose of the vehicle being parked was to collect a passenger. The fact that assistance then had to be provided due to an emergency situation does not alter the reason for the vehicle being stopped. I would not in any case regard a period of parking of 10 minutes to be excessive for collecting an elderly passenger and helping them back to the vehicle. I am satisfied on balance that the picking up exemption applies in this case.
« Last Edit: February 03, 2026, 03:33:51 pm by stamfordman »

How does the following sound as a letter of appeal?

Quote
03 Feb 2025

Dear Sir/Madam,

PCN Number: AO08385708
Date of Service of this Notice: 21/01/2026
Location: Ruislip Road East (GRE) op Leyland
Contravention: 25 – Parked in a loading place or bay during restricted hours without loading

Thank you for your correspondence about the above PCN.

I was collecting my mother from her friend’s apartment, located in x. She has severe arthritis and finds it difficult to walk short distances and needs assistance when walking down steps.

This fits in with the assisted boarding exemption to stop in restricted areas.

Please find attached a copy of her blue badge for your perusal.

I look forward to hearing from you.

Yours sincerely,

Fine. YOu don't want to say too much in what is, after all, only an informal challenge. It allows them to reject and also write a load of tosh about the boarding exemption which they hope will encourage you to cough-up. So submit this, and post up their inevitable rejection when you get it.