Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - AndyT008

Pages: [1]
1
Hello

I would be grateful for your advice in regard to the likelihood of the defendant being able to recover their costs in a particular small claims case that was eventually struck out for the claimant’s failure to pay the trial fee. The details of that defended claim are as follows.

Euro Car Parks and DCB Legal, a boiler plate claim for payment in relation to an alleged parking contravention. The Particulars of Claim did not provide sufficient detail for the defendant to understand the cause of the claim. The defence set out the further details that were needed, but the claimant chose to proceed and not provide any of that detail. The defendant asked for the missing details again during the mediation call, but the person attending the call for the claimant could/would not provide the detail.

The claim was then allocated to the small claims track and the judge made an order setting out what the parties must do before the hearing date. The claimant did not comply with any of that order; failing to provide a witness statement, failing to give the additional specific details of the parking contravention (as set out in the order), and finally did not pay the trial fee. The defendant complied with the order, and on time filed and served their witness statements (x2).

The claim was eventually struck out by the court when the claimant missed the deadline for paying the trial fee. Interestingly, the notice of trial date document, issued by the court with the order, specifically stated that should the trial fee not be paid by the due date the claimant would be liable for the costs which the defendant had incurred. Would the wording in that notice about costs carry any weight on the small claims track?

Thanks.

2
Private parking tickets / Re: ECP / DCB Court Claim - Advice Appreciated
« on: December 01, 2025, 02:05:55 pm »
b789 - wow! - thank you for your reply to my questions - that is very helpful.

3
Private parking tickets / Re: ECP / DCB Court Claim - Advice Appreciated
« on: December 01, 2025, 10:05:02 am »
Hello

Hello helpful people - an observation, and a couple of questions, about the timeline to the trial date for this case.

OBSERVATION
The trial date is 25 February 2026.
The trial fee payment deadline is 28 January 2026.
The deadline for the Witness Statements is given as 4pm on 19 December 2025.

QUESTION
Is it normal to have the WS date so early? - six weeks before the trial fee deadline.
Do you think the claimant will file their WS that early? - or will they deliberately miss the date so they have the defendant's WS first.

I would appreciate your view on those questions - thanks.


4
Thank you 'just love cars' for your reply.

To answer your question - NO: no appeals were made because the PCN went to a previous address. I moved address literally 2 days after the date that the parking took place. Only got the PCN several months later when I visited the previous address and the new tenant handed over some old mail.

5
Hello – hoping you can provide advice on what a suitable defence might be for this particular parking case.

1. The driver parked a vehicle in a car park operated by Euro Car Parks.
2. The car park signage advertised 2 hours free parking.
3. The driver exited the car park 2 hours and 10 minutes later.
4. ECP issued a PCN for £100 in October 2023 which remains unpaid.
5. The reason given for the PCN was ‘The vehicle was parked without a valid Pay by
Phone transaction’.
6. ECP have now made a Court Claim for £277 (DCB Legal appear to be handling the `claim for ECP).
7. The defendant named in the Claim is the Registered Keeper of the vehicle.
8. The defendant has submitted the ‘acknowledgment of service’ for the Claim and will provide a defence. It is the content of that defence I am hoping you can help with?

Attachments
a) ECP Notice to Keeper (& PCN)
b) ECP Court Claim
c) Car park signage – 2 hours free parking

[ Guests cannot view attachments ]

Pages: [1]