Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - katieannetobin

Pages: [1]
1
Sorry! I didn't realise all correspondance hadn't attached. Sorted now.

2
Sorry! I've attached now. It's very short as no repsonse to my previous questions.

3
I got a ticket for leaving my car parked on my road which unfortuantely became suspended while I was away. The offence is listed as 21 parking wholly or partly in a suspended bay. The council claim that most suspensions are notified with physical sinage well in advance, but refuse to email residents as it's 'not an appropriate use of council time or resources'. (No response when I asked why they can email to make my fill in surveys, though.) They claim it is 'residents repsonsibility to check on their car everyday without fail', meaning I can effectively never spend a night away from my house without being worried I can get a ticket.

After appealing between August and December, they finally introduced mitigating circumstances for vulnerable residents and to evidence I'd been on holiday, but only out of UK travel. They totally ignored my query about inter-UK travel, my recent hospital discharge letter, or that I've been made redundant. They also insisted that online and via email that it would not rise to £130, which it has, even after it still said on the portal that it was £65. I've sent them a screenshot of this.

I've attached their last response. They have not supplied evidence of when the suspension signs were posted. I am awaiting all my letters to them as a DSAR but I've said this:

The council’s handling of this matter contravenes multiple laws and regulations, including but not limited to:

    Regulation 18, Local Authorities’ Traffic Orders (Procedure) (England and Wales) Regulations 1996: Failure to adequately inform the public of parking restrictions.
    Equality Act 2010: Failure to make reasonable adjustments for vulnerable individuals.
    Freedom of Information Act 2000 and GDPR: Failure to provide requested evidence regarding PCNs and suspension signage.
    Public Law Principles: Issuance of contradictory and misleading information regarding payment amounts.

Here is all my correspondance from the Council. I am at the Notice to Owner stage: https://imgur.com/a/fT8IeU2

The exact location can be seen here, at 2 Raleigh Road, Harringay, London, N8 0JB: https://www.google.com/maps/@51.5878807,-0.108581,3a,75y,114.26h,90t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sqaqunDQ0Y-kG6qZFNxGCHg!2e0!6shttps:%2F%2Fstreetviewpixels-pa.googleapis.com%2Fv1%2Fthumbnail%3Fcb_client%3Dmaps_sv.tactile%26w%3D900%26h%3D600%26pitch%3D0%26panoid%3DqaqunDQ0Y-kG6qZFNxGCHg%26yaw%3D114.26220337850079!7i16384!8i8192?entry=ttu&g_ep=EgoyMDI1MDEwNi4xIKXMDSoASAFQAw%3D%3D

4
Thanks for your guidance. Annoyingly, it's coming up to the deadline to pay and no word from the council. Fortunately I have a few friends who are lawyers who helped me word my response:


Thank you for your response. However, I must respectfully disagree with your decision and would like to address several points regarding the penalty and the circumstances surrounding it. I have contested the ticket once again, attaching this letter on the online portal, and request that the PCNs go on hold while I await your response to this letter. Please confirm you have done so.

While I understand that my car was in a bay subject to suspension, I find the expectation that drivers must "check on their car every day" to be unreasonable, particularly when the council has failed to provide sufficient notice of the suspension. The signs, as mentioned in your letter, may have been put up, but I was not made aware via email or other direct communication, despite the fact that Haringey Council holds my contact information. Given this, it was entirely possible and reasonable for me to believe that the area was still available for parking during my absence.

Furthermore, the notion that drivers should check their vehicles every day, regardless of circumstance, is impractical and does not take into account situations where this would be impossible. In my case, I was away on holiday and also severely ill, circumstances which clearly impeded my ability to monitor my vehicle. Others may similarly face obstacles, such as hospital admissions or emergencies, and under your current policy, they too would be unfairly penalized. The responsibility to inform residents of such suspensions should not rest solely on vague signage that can be missed if one is unable to check daily.

Additionally, the Penalty Charge Notice appears to be inaccurate in stating the nature of the contravention. It suggests that I was parked in an electric vehicle bay, yet there are no such bays on my street. This error further highlights the lack of attention to detail in issuing this notice, which not only undermines the accuracy of the penalty but also raises concerns about the validity of the enforcement process.

On top of this, the misspelling of my name in your correspondence demonstrates a general lack of care in handling this matter. I expect due diligence from a local authority in both the accuracy of the penalty details and the correct identification of residents, particularly when financial penalties are at stake.

I have sought legal advice on this matter and am prepared to challenge this penalty further, as I believe the law is on my side. The council’s failure to provide adequate notice through modern, accessible channels, its reliance on an unreasonable expectation of daily vehicle checks, and the inaccuracy in the contravention all contribute to this unjust penalty.

I kindly request that you reconsider this Penalty Charge Notice, as I am confident that my argument is legally sound and I will pursue this matter if necessary.

Thank you for your attention to this matter.

6
I live on a permit only street and went away for a week. To my shock, I received two parking tickets for parking in a suspended bay, one of which was allegedly for electric vehicles when there are no electric vehicle bays on my street. I suspect - and based on discussions with neighbours - that the suspension signs were put up with only a few days notice. I tried to appeal but their retort was this: 'Before we suspend parking bays, we have to put up warning signs and we did this. It is up to drivers to check on their cars every day to make sure that the parking bay is not being suspended.' I have a permit account with my email but received no email notice of these ongoing works. Even a ticket officer I spoke to about it in person said it's grossly unfair!

They've also spelled my name wrong on the letter, which doesn’t fill me with confidence that these are attention-oriented people.

Pages: [1]