Author Topic: Sheffield City Council PCN  (Read 261 times)

0 Members and 93 Guests are viewing this topic.

Sheffield City Council PCN
« on: »
On 23/12/24 I received a PCN that seemed wildly unfair and I am even wondering if I have grounds to put in a complaint, never-mind just appeal. It sounds ridiculous, but this really is an honest description of what happened:

I pulled up in a street parking bay, and walked away from the car to find the nearest machine so I could see the number in which to pay on my app. As I walked over to do this, a mother struggling with shopping bags and her children stopped me to ask for help in ordering a taxi. The mum didn't speak English and her child had to translate between us. Of course I tried to help them, which perhaps took about 5 minutes. As I was coming to the end of this I noticed a traffic warden with his machine out by my car so I literally ran over and said to him "I'm just about to get a ticket, which is the nearest machine?" (so he knew my intent) He pointed to the opposite direction I came from and then started talking to another man whose car was there. I stood beside him & waited for about 1 minute until he was done with his conversation so I could ask if I could use the code on the closer machine, but before I even had chance to do that he slapped a PCN on my car.

I said "why did you do that? I literally told you I'm about to buy a ticket."
Warden: "I didn't know that was your car."
Me: "How could you not know, I ran over the road to tell you I was just about to buy a ticket?"
Warden: "I didn't know."
Me: "I was on my way to buy a ticket and I just stopped briefly to help a family who couldn't speak English."
Warden: "Okay well sorry, maybe you can appeal it. I was observing your car for about 10 minutes."
Me: "That doesn't sound right."
Warden: "There's nothing I can do, you can try and appeal it. You should've told me that was your car."

Then he walked off. I checked the ticket and the observation time was only for 4 minutes.

Do I have grounds to appeal this? It feels very unfair.


[ Guests cannot view attachments ]

Share on Bluesky Share on Facebook


Re: Sheffield City Council PCN
« Reply #1 on: »
Well, of course you can appeal it !  You have the absolute right in law to take the council all the way to the adjudicators, but would, in all likelihood, have to forego the discount option, (see your PCN) if you want to succeed.

You need to be aware that councils ruthlessly game the system to maximise their cash flow, so your initial representations will, in all likelihood, be rejected, thus forcing your to either cough-up, or wait for the next stage, the Notice to Owner. Under the legislation, the vehicle owner has total responsibility for a PCN, so if you are minded to take them all the way, are you the owner, and is your V5C Registration Certificate for the car up-to-date ? The NtO is sent to the name and address on the V5C.