Skip to content

Police Claiming the Online form was completed incorrectly and that they sent postal correspondence about this.

758 Views 21 Replies

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

#1
Hi

I am hoping for some guidance on this.
Caught doing 47 in a 40MPH zone. Questioned the timestamps when entered the zone being recorded. Accepted their explanation and filled in online form to respond to NIP on 23rd June. Screenshot of confirmation screen was taken. Heard nothing since, thought nothing of it.
This month recieved SJPN for failure to furnish.
I emailed the police camera unit with the screenshot. They are now saying:

  • Driving licence number was provided in place of name
  • Signature required full name
  • They sent postal correspondence on 24th June to me.

I do not have a screenshot of this so have no way to verify and I did not recieve any postal notice. At this stage I am starting to doubt their systems (West Yorkshire Police)

So what are my options? Plead NG to both charges on the SJPN and fancy my chances? As far as I am aware I filled in the form properly and I can confirm 100% I did not recieve any post from them about the form submission being wrong.
#2
You could start by clearly setting out what has happened. You have mention receiving an SJPN for an s. 172 offence, and are asking us if you should plead not guilty to *both* charges.

What does the evidence in the SJPN bundle say?
I am responsible for the accuracy of the information I post, not your ability to comprehend it.
#4
@Nazia

1  Some police forces will not allow you to nominate yourself online as the driver - they demand a signed paper "admission".  What were you asked to do?

2  Did you give your DL number where you should have given your name?

3  I nominated myself online as a driver three years ago.  In the signature box I had to give my full name.  Did you?

#6
There are lots of these cases here if you search.  If you plead NG to both, but put in the mitigation that you will plead guilty to the speeding if, and only if, they drop the FTF charge.  This deal is almost always accepted and usually these days without going to court.  You can also ask to be sentenced at the Fixed Penalty level since you believed you had complied with requirements - this doesn't always work, but mothing to lose by asking.

Defending the FTF seems tricky, since the Police will no doubt produce the print out showing the details wrongly entered - whether that is down to a screw up at your end or theirs you can't evidence without a screen shot of what you actually put in.

#8
There are lots of these cases here if you search.  If you plead NG to both, but put in the mitigation that you will plead guilty to the speeding if, and only if, they drop the FTF charge.  This deal is almost always accepted and usually these days without going to court.  You can also ask to be sentenced at the Fixed Penalty level since you believed you had complied with requirements - this doesn't always work, but mothing to lose by asking.

Defending the FTF seems tricky, since the Police will no doubt produce the print out showing the details wrongly entered - whether that is down to a screw up at your end or theirs you can't evidence without a screen shot of what you actually put in.

Thanks

At what stage do they need to produce the evidence/print out?
#10
You should have received he evidence the police intend to rely on to convict you, along with your SJPN.

If you haven’t got it, ask for it. It might help you understand how you have failed to comply with the request (or even indicate that you have complied).

But, as above, you won’t need it if you choose to request the “deal”.
#11
You should have received he evidence the police intend to rely on to convict you, along with your SJPN.

If you haven’t got it, ask for it. It might help you understand how you have failed to comply with the request (or even indicate that you have complied).

But, as above, you won’t need it if you choose to request the “deal”.

No evidence sent with the SJPN. It was by email they say the form was incorrectly completed but no evidence of this in SJPN pack. That just says failed to reply by deadline.
#12
Quote
You won't get their evidence unless you plead not guilty,

Before entering a plea, the prosecution should have served on the defendant:

(a)a summary of the evidence on which the prosecution case is based;

(b)any—

  (i)written witness statement to which Part 16 (Written witness statements) applies, or

  (ii)document or extract setting out facts; or

(c)any combination of such a summary, statement, document or extract.


[The above is from the Criminal Procedure Rules, s24(9)]

If they are alleging that he responded but that his response was inadequate or did not meet their requirements, then I would say that a copy of that response should be provided to the defendant.

He was initially told that his response did not meet the requirements. But now, along with the SJPN, he has been told that he did not respond.

The idea of providing this stuff is to enable the defendant to decide how to plead. He can’t do that unless he knows what is alleged and what the police will produce to convict him.

He has three weeks after the service of that material to enter a plea. He should contact the police to get clarification of exactly what is alleged and to be provided with the required material.

Unless, of course, he wants to do the “deal”, in which case he needn’t bother. But he’s entitled to have this stuff, even if he is considering the deal because he might, instead,  want to argue that he has complied with the request.
Last Edit: November 07, 2026, 06:39:08 pm by NewJudge
#13
Apologies I should have set this out from the outset:

1. Received NIP in May. Replied in June online, within the deadline. Took screenshot of submission screen. Heard nothing back. Thought perhaps they had a backlog or cancelled on a technicality (wishful thinking!)

2. October. Received SJPN. Says failure it furnish within deadline.

3. immediately emailed the camera unit, saying along lines of: must be some mistake, here is the screenshot.

4. They reply saying signature issue OR driving license in place of name.

5. Emailed back, disagreeing and asking for reconsideration.

6. They reply, doubling down and saying we need to reply to SJPN.