Skip to content

NPC — DCB Legal — County Court Claim — Myrtle Parade, Liverpool L77AA — Failure to Pay for Duration of Stay

26 Views 1 Replies

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

#1
NPC — DCB Legal — County Court Claim
Myrtle Parade, Liverpool L77AA — Failure to Pay for Duration of Stay
Parking Company:  National Parking Control Group Limited (NPC)
Solicitors:  DCB Legal Ltd
Location:  Myrtle Parade (ANPR), Liverpool, L77AA (Tesco Express car park)
Date of event:  29/03/2026
PCN Number:  ANPR315998
Claim form:  N1SDT received — Claim issued 21 October 2026
AoS filed:  4 November 2026 — defending all of the claim
Defence deadline:  23 November 2026
What Happened
On 29/03/2026 the vehicle entered the Myrtle Parade car park (Tesco Express). Passengers exited and used the nearby shops — bought a bubble tea, used the toilet, and went into Tesco.
The vehicle was attended throughout with the engine running. The driver never exited the vehicle. The vehicle was repositioned during the stay after a pigeon defecated on it. The engine was never turned off and the vehicle was never “parked” in any conventional sense — it was an attended pickup/drop-off.
The driver has not been identified to NPC at any point.
ANPR recorded:
Entry:  17:04:06
Exit:  17:19:16
Duration:  15 minutes 10 seconds
The NPC sign at the car park states: “All vehicles must obtain a pay to park session within 15 minutes of entry to the car park.”
PCN / Notice to Keeper
NPC posted a Parking Charge Notice / Notice to Keeper dated 07 April 2026 (9 days after the event).
Charge:  £100 (reduced to £60 if paid within 14 days)
Reason:  Failure to pay for the duration of stay
Code:  The notice states adherence to an “ATA Code of Practice”
The charge was not paid or appealed.
The Claim
DCB Legal filed a county court claim (N1SDT) issued 21 October 2026.
Particulars of Claim:
Para 1:  Defendant indebted for a Parking Charge issued to vehicle at Myrtle Parade (ANPR), Liverpool L77AA
Para 2:  Date of contravention 29/03/2026
Para 3:  Defendant pursued as the driver for breach of the terms on the signs (Failure To Pay For The Duration Of Stay)
Para 4:  In the alternative, Defendant pursued as keeper under POFA 2012 Schedule 4
Amounts:
Amount claimed:  £170.00 (PC and damages) + £7.08 interest at 8% = £177.08
Court fee:  £35.00
Legal representative’s costs:  £50.00
Total:  £262.08
Signed by David John Croot (Claimant’s Legal Representative).
Key Points I’ve Identified
1.  Vehicle was never parked — Engine running, attended throughout, repositioned during the stay, driver never exited. No contract formed.
2.  Within NPC’s own 15-minute window — Total stay was 15 min 10 sec. NPC’s own sign allows 15 minutes to obtain a session. Consideration period under the Code of Practice should also apply.
3.  Claim exceeds POFA maximum — The claim is for £170 but the NtK states £100. This appears to exceed the POFA Schedule 4 para 4(5) maximum sum recoverable from the keeper.
4.  Driver not identified — The driver has not been identified to NPC at any point.
5.  ATA Code of Practice reference — The NtK refers to an “ATA Code of Practice” — unsure whether this is current/correct.
Questions
1.  Can anyone help review the NtK for POFA Schedule 4 para 9(2) compliance? I have photos of the original notice.
2.  Is the “not parked / waiting with engine running” argument effective at this level?
3.  Any other defences I should be raising?
4.  Happy to upload redacted images of the claim form, NtK, and car park signage.
Any help with drafting the defence would be much appreciated. Thanks in advance.
#2
Of course you should upload images, as requested in http://www.ftla.uk/private-parking-tickets/read-this-first-private-parking-charges-forum-guide/

Note that you have to file an Acknowledgment of Service or a defence by 4pm on 9 November.
If you file an AoS you have until 4pm on 23 November to file your defence.

Your defence should explicitly respond to the Particulars of Claim, in each case expanding on why you deny them based on your evidence and on the original NtK.

In my opinion, sitting in a stationary car in a car park, whether or not the engine is running, is “parking”. So do others, see https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/private-parking-code-of-practice/private-parking-code-of-practice for example:
Quote
2.17 Parked/parking

An instance of a vehicle being caused by the driver to remain stationary other than in the course of driving (excluding instances where the driver has stopped temporarily to enable passengers to leave or enter the vehicle not including drop-off zones such as those at airports in scope of the Code or other facilities designed for dropping off and picking up passengers).

A vehicle may be deemed to be parked whether or not the driver has left the vehicle or turned off the ignition.
A contract is formed by staying in the car park for longer than the "consideration period" or - sooner - by parking, unless there are other circumstances such as a traffic jam. That's what they'll say, anyway.
Last Edit: November 04, 2026, 12:47:05 pm by jfollows