Skip to content

Horizon Parking NTK, Epping Forest Barn Hoppitt, stay was after published 18:30 closing/charging time

93 Views 8 Replies

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

#1
Hi everyone,

I'm the registered keeper and have received a Notice to Keeper from Horizon Parking (BPA member).

  • Location: Epping Forest Barn Hoppitt Car Park (landowner: City of London Corporation)
  • Alleged breach: "Failure to Pay for Full Duration of Stay", 27 September 2026
  • ANPR times: entry 18:55:18, exit 19:10:54
  • Notice dated 7 October 2026. I received it on 12 October 2026 (no ticket was left on the vehicle).
  • Amount: £60 if paid within 14 days, then £100

The landowner's website says charges apply during car park opening hours and that from 15 September 2026 the car parks close at 6:30pm. RingGo's listing for the car park shows charge times of 7:00am to 6:30pm and says durations are reduced to meet an 18:30 cutoff (last tariff update 11 September 2026). I don't have photos of the signs.

Both sides of the notice are attached (details redacted), along with screenshots of the RingGo listing. My draft appeal is below. I'd really appreciate views on:

  • Does the NTK meet the PoFA Schedule 4 paragraph 9 requirements?
  • Is the charging-hours argument sound, and what could Horizon say back?
  • Anything I should change in my draft before sending?

Draft appeal:

Quote
Re: Parking Charge Notice HP5576355 - Vehicle REDACTED - Epping Forest Barn Hoppitt Car Park - alleged event 27 September 2026

Quote
I am the registered keeper of this vehicle and I dispute this parking charge. I deny liability and any contractual agreement. I make no admission as to who was driving, and no inference may be drawn.

Quote
1. No payment was due for the period alleged. Your notice alleges "Failure to Pay for Full Duration of Stay". Your own ANPR images record entry at 18:55:18 and exit at 19:10:54. The landowner, the City of London Corporation (Epping Forest), publishes that charges apply during car park opening hours and that its car parks close at 6:30pm from 15 September 2026. The RingGo listing for this car park, last updated on 11 September 2026, gives charge times of 7:00am to 6:30pm and states that parking durations are reduced to meet an 18:30 cutoff. On that basis the whole of the recorded stay fell outside the period in which payment was required. Please identify the specific term you say was breached and the sign on which you rely, and state the charging hours you say applied on 27 September 2026.

Quote
2. Signage. I put you to strict proof that the terms you rely on were prominently displayed, legible and adequately lit at the entrance and within the car park at the time of the alleged event, which was after 18:55 at around dusk. Please provide dated, close-up photographs of every sign relied upon, showing their positions and how they were lit at that time.

Quote
3. Keeper liability. I put you to strict proof of the date on which your Notice to Keeper was posted and that it was given within the period required by paragraph 9 of Schedule 4 to the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012. I first received it on 12 October 2026. If those conditions are not met, liability cannot be transferred to the keeper, and I am under no obligation to identify the driver.

Quote
4. Evidence. Please also supply the landowner contract or authority allowing you to issue charges at this site, the complete ANPR records for this vehicle for the event, and any payment records you hold for this registration on that date.

Quote
If you reject this appeal, please provide your full evidence and the POPLA verification code.

Quote
[REDACTED NAME] - Registered keeper - [REDACTED ADDRESS]

Screenshots of the notice and the RingGo listing:











Links:


Landowner email:

I also plan on e-mailing the landowner (epping.forest@cityoflondon.gov.uk) in addition to the appeal. My draft is below, and I'd welcome comments on this too. Thank you!

Quote
Subject: Request to confirm hours and cancel Horizon PCN REDACTED - Barn Hoppitt Car Park

Quote
Dear Epping Forest Team,

Quote
I am the registered keeper of vehicle REDACTED and have received Horizon Parking Charge Notice REDACTED for Barn Hoppitt Car Park on 27 September 2026, alleging failure to pay for the full duration of the stay.

Quote
Horizon's ANPR images record the vehicle entering at 18:55 and leaving at 19:10. Your published information says charges apply during car park opening hours and that Epping Forest car parks close at 6:30pm from 15 September 2026. RingGo's listing for the car park also gives charge times of 7:00am to 6:30pm.

Quote
Could you please confirm the opening and charging hours that applied at Barn Hoppitt on 27 September 2026? If charges did not apply at those times, I would be grateful if you could ask Horizon to cancel the notice. A written reply I can reference in my appeal would be very helpful.

Quote
Kind regards, [REDACTED NAME] - [REDACTED ADDRESS] - PCN: REDACTED | Vehicle: REDACTED
#3
If this is a council provided car park then POFA cannot apply at this location.

Make sure that the driver is never revealed in any appeals / letters etc.

Thank you, that's really helpful. I've now read Schedule 4 paragraph 3. The car park is within Epping Forest, held by the City of London Corporation as Conservators, and the Epping Forest Byelaws 1980 (byelaw 3(11)) make it an offence to leave a vehicle in the Forest except in listed circumstances, including in a vehicle park during the hours prescribed by the Conservators. Byelaw 5 sets the penalty. I think that makes parking there "subject to statutory control" under 3(1)(c), 3(3) and 3(4), so it isn't relevant land and keeper liability can't arise.

I've reworked my appeal to lead with that point and keep the charging hours and signage points after it. Would you agree with that order, and is there anything Horizon could say against it? I'll make sure the driver is never identified.

Revised appeal:

Quote
Re: Parking Charge Notice REDACTED - Vehicle REDACTED - Epping Forest Barn Hoppitt Car Park - alleged event 27 September 2026

Quote
I am the registered keeper of this vehicle and I dispute this parking charge. I deny liability and any contractual agreement. I make no admission as to who was driving, and no inference may be drawn.

Quote
1. Keeper liability. Barn Hoppitt Car Park is within Epping Forest, land held by the City of London Corporation as Conservators of Epping Forest and subject to the Epping Forest Byelaws, made under the Epping Forest Acts 1878 and 1880 and the City of London (Various Powers) Act 1977. Byelaw 3(11) makes it an offence to leave a vehicle in or on the Forest except in specified circumstances, including in a vehicle park during the hours prescribed by the Conservators, and byelaw 5 provides a penalty on conviction. The parking of vehicles on this land is therefore subject to statutory control within paragraphs 3(1)(c), 3(3) and 3(4) of Schedule 4 to the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012. It is not "relevant land", and Schedule 4 gives you no right to recover from the keeper. I put you to strict proof that it is relevant land. In any event, I put you to strict proof that your Notice to Keeper complies with every requirement of paragraph 9, including paragraphs 9(2)(c) and 9(2)(i), and that it was given within 14 days beginning the day after the alleged parking ended (paragraphs 9(4) to 9(6)). I first received it on 12 October 2026. I am under no obligation to identify the driver.

Quote
2. No payment was due for the period alleged. Your notice alleges "Failure to Pay for Full Duration of Stay". Your own ANPR images record entry at 18:55:18 and exit at 19:10:54. The landowner, the City of London Corporation (Epping Forest), publishes that charges apply during car park opening hours and that its car parks close at 6:30pm from 15 September 2026. The RingGo listing for this car park, last updated on 11 September 2026, gives charge times of 7:00am to 6:30pm and states that parking durations are reduced to meet an 18:30 cutoff. On that basis the whole of the recorded stay fell outside the period in which payment was required. Please identify the specific term you say was breached and the sign on which you rely, and state the charging hours you say applied on 27 September 2026.

Quote
3. Signage. I put you to strict proof that the terms you rely on were prominently displayed, legible and adequately lit at the entrance and within the car park at the time of the alleged event, which was after 18:55 at around dusk. Please provide dated, close-up photographs of every sign relied upon, showing their positions and how they were lit at that time.

Quote
4. Evidence. Please also supply the landowner contract or authority allowing you to issue charges at this site, including how it deals with the Epping Forest Byelaws, the complete ANPR records for this vehicle for the event, and any payment records you hold for this registration on that date.

Quote
If you reject this appeal, please provide your full evidence and the POPLA verification code.

Quote
[REDACTED NAME] - Registered keeper - [REDACTED ADDRESS]
#4
You could mention that the Code of Practice expressly forbids a parking operator from claiming reliance on POFA at locations where POFA cannot apply - therefore, the obtaining of keeper data was made in breach of the KODOE contract with the DVLA - therefore, the PCN is incorrectly issued.
#5
You could mention that the Code of Practice expressly forbids a parking operator from claiming reliance on POFA at locations where POFA cannot apply - therefore, the obtaining of keeper data was made in breach of the KODOE contract with the DVLA - therefore, the PCN is incorrectly issued.

Thank you, that's a useful point 8) . Could you confirm the section of the Single Code of Practice you have in mind? I've seen 8.1.1(d) quoted for operators stating or implying PoFA keeper liability where the land isn't relevant land, and I'll check the wording on the BPA site before adding it. The NtK expressly relies on paragraph 9(2)(f) of Schedule 4, so I think it would apply. Would you save the DVLA/BPA complaint route for after Horizon's appeal response?
#9
Evening all. I have submitted the appeal to Horizon and Epping Forest. Thanks!

Could you please post up the appeal wording.

Purely for continuity.

Thanks, here is the wording I submitted via the Horizon portal. The comments box had a short summary and I attached the full appeal as a PDF (identical to the revised draft earlier in the thread).

Portal comments box:

Quote
I am the registered keeper and I dispute this parking charge. I deny liability and make no admission as to who was driving. Barn Hoppitt Car Park is within Epping Forest and subject to the Epping Forest Byelaws (byelaw 3(11)), so parking there is subject to statutory control and the land is not "relevant land" under paragraph 3(1)(c) of Schedule 4 to the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012. I cannot be held liable as keeper. Your ANPR images record entry at 18:55:18 and exit at 19:10:54, after the published 18:30 closing and charging time, so no payment was due. Please see my full appeal attached and supply the evidence it requests. If you reject this appeal, please provide the POPLA verification code.

Attached PDF: the four-point revised appeal (keeper liability / relevant land, no payment due, signage, evidence) as posted earlier.

Reply from Epping Forest:

Quote
Thank you for contacting us regarding your PCN. As you may be aware, the car parks are situated on Epping Forest land, and the infrastructure within them is the property of Epping Forest. However, Epping Forest has entered into contractual agreements with two external partners: RingGo, who provide the parking payment platform, and Horizon Parking, who are responsible for enforcement and the management of pay machines at several of our car parks. As a result of this outsourcing, Epping Forest is no longer directly involved with individual cases. However I understand that you would have received this PCN as you were parked when the car park was officially shut. Barn Hoppit Car Park closed at 6.30pm on the 27th September 2026. Please liaise directly with Horizon if you want to appeal this PCN.

I'll hold this for POPLA if Horizon rejects. Thoughts welcome on whether the "officially shut" comment gives Horizon room to switch to a different breach, and how to answer that.


Update: Horizon has cancelled the PCN (as a "gesture of goodwill") following my keeper appeal, so no POPLA needed. Thanks all, especially InterCity125 for the relevant land point.