Skip to content

Horizon Parking Limited - Claim Form Received - Provident Square Chelmsford

6787 Views 51 Replies

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

#31
See similar tactics from Horizon at http://www.ftla.uk/private-parking-tickets/hearing-date-set-for-private-parking-ticket-from-horizon-parking-ltd/, there I suggested that the defendant objects to the arrogance of Horizon in not attending court, although their request not to do so is in compliance with the civil procedure rules.
#35
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1ZKRmkJSYA2Xu7R72Y3uCdz7Uosjm7rEO/view?usp=sharing

Could someone confirm whether this link works please.

There's a lot of case law they put here. Is that the same expectation for the Defendant to do in theirs as well? Are their arguments strong?
#36
So the PCN which they show in the WS is not PoFA compliant.

The WS implies that they are in some way relying on PoFA keeper liability but you can easily rebut this as the correct wording is not contained within the PCN.

Additionally, the PCN is not deemed to be served in time for keeper liability to occur - the parking event occurred on 21st Dec 2024 but the NtK was only deemed to be served on 6th Jan 2025 (might be worth someone else checking my understanding on that point) - either way, the notice is not PoFA compliant anyway.

Your witness statement should reference  Barclays Bank v Various Claimants (2020) when dealing with the allegation of vicarious liability.

Vicarious liability is where they suggest that someone driving the vehicle automatically became the agent for the company.

You should categorically rebut the allegation of vicarious liability on the grounds that the Claimant has presented no evidence whatsoever which demonstrates that the driver of the vehicle was acting on behalf of the company at the material time  - as a matter of legal principle, it is not for the Defendant to rebut evidence which is not presented by the Claimant - in order to demonstrate vicarious liability, the Claimant must put forward the evidence which shows that the driver was acting for the Defendant at the material time - no such evidence exists and therefore there is no evidence for the Defendant to rebut.

Point out that the company allows individuals use of the vehicles for private use (if that is true).

The Claimant's claim is 'scatter gun' in nature with no legitimate route to liability.

Despite their big WS, this is easy to defend.
#38
Is there any chance we could see the original claim form?

The reason I ask is so we can see if they are claiming vicarious liability in the original claim or if they are simply seeking keeper liability under PoFA.

If they've introduced vicarious liability at a stage beyond the claim then really the Court should strike out the claim.
#39
How can a WS include anything unrelated to the PoC?

The OP posted the PoC in narrative form but not the claim form. As far as I can see, the only basis on which the parking charge is pursued against the defendant is:

The Particular of claims are as follows:

The driver of motor vehicle registration XXXX parked in breach of the prominently displayed terms and conditions of parking set out on the signage at Provident Square Chelmsford on 21/12/2024. The signage constituted an offer of a unilateral contract, accepted by the act of parking, under which the driver agreed to pay the specified parking charge (the PCN) in the event of breach. The PCN remains unpaid after 28 days and the defendant, as driver and/or registered keeper, is liable for the outstanding sum. Despite demands, the Defendant has failed to make payment. The claimant therefore claims £90 for the PCN, £70 contractual costs pursuant to the Contract and PCN terms and conditions together with statutory interest of £13.41 pursuant to s69 of the County Courts Act 1984 at 8% per annum, accruing at £0.04 per day until judgement or earlier payment.

The WS states at para. 23..
That they do not rely solely on the statutory keeper liability provisions...rather that they are contractually liable through the acts of its authorised driver.

But this isn't mentioned in the PoC.

There's no PoFA liability and the initial bespoke Horizon PCN doesn't even claim that the keeper is liable.

So, should the claim stand when the WS refers to a completely different basis of liability?

And GS6 is not consistent with GS5 as regards dates. Was this a deliberate attempt to bring the matter within the 14-day relevant period or just a c**k-up.
#40
This is the defence I submitted at the time:

Defence

Introduction
The Defendant denies that the Claimant is entitled to the relief claimed, or at all.
The Defendant is a limited company and the registered keeper of the vehicle referred to in the Particulars of Claim.
The Particulars of Claim are sparse and fail to identify:
the precise contractual term allegedly breached,
the conduct said to constitute breach,
the legal basis for the additional sums claimed,
the signage relied upon,
or how the sum of £90 is derived when the signage states £85.
The Defendant is therefore unable to fully understand the case being pursued and reserves the right to amend or supplement this Defence should the Claimant provide further particulars.
Driver identity is not admitted
The Claimant alleges that the Defendant is liable as “driver and/or registered keeper”.
The Defendant is a corporate entity and therefore cannot have been the driver of the vehicle
The Defendant is under no legal obligation to identify the driver and declines to do so.
The Claimant is therefore put to strict proof as to the identity of the driver at the time of the alleged event.
Failure to establish keeper liability
In order to pursue the registered keeper, the Claimant must demonstrate full compliance with Schedule 4 of the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012.
The Defendant does not recall receiving the Notice to Keeper and no such document is presently available to the Defendant.
The Claimant is therefore put to strict proof that a Notice to Keeper was served and that it fully complied with all mandatory requirements of Schedule 4 of the Act.


In particular, the Claimant must demonstrate compliance with the statutory requirements including but not limited to:
specifying the period of parking,
identifying the creditor,
providing the mandatory warning of keeper liability, and
delivering the notice within the required statutory timeframe.
In the absence of strict compliance with these provisions, the Claimant cannot transfer liability from the driver to the registered keeper.
As the Defendant is a company and cannot have been the driver, the claim must fail in the absence of valid keeper liability.
Entitlement to park and compliance with site conditions
The signage relied upon by the Claimant states that a parking charge may be issued for:
“Failure to validate parking or pay for the full duration of stay”
On the material date (21 December 2024), the driver made a purchase exceeding £5 at a participating retailer in order to obtain a parking voucher as required by the site’s parking system.
The Defendant retains evidence of this transaction in the form of a bank statement confirming that the purchase was made during the relevant period.
It is the Defendant’s honest belief that the voucher code was entered into the validation machine provided for that purpose.
If the Claimant alleges that the voucher was not successfully registered, this may indicate a failure or inadequacy in the Claimant’s validation system rather than a failure by the motorist to comply with the parking terms.
The Claimant is therefore put to strict proof of:
validation machine records for the relevant date and time,
system logs showing voucher entries,
evidence that the validation machine was functioning correctly on the material date.
The Defendant denies any intentional or negligent failure to comply with the parking conditions.
Distinction from the Beavis case
The Claimant may seek to rely upon ParkingEye Ltd v Beavis [2015] UKSC 67, where a parking charge was held to be enforceable in certain circumstances.
However, that case concerned a clearly communicated charge in a retail car park where the motorist overstayed a permitted period.
The present case is distinguished because the driver made the required purchase to obtain a parking voucher and was therefore entitled to park under the scheme operating at the site.
Any alleged failure to validate a voucher would represent a minor or technical issue rather than the deliberate overstay considered in the Beavis case.
The additional £70 is unlawful and unrecoverable
The Claimant seeks to recover an additional £70 described as “contractual costs”.
The Defendant denies that this sum is recoverable and argues it is in breach of CPR 27.
The parking charge itself already includes the costs of operating the parking scheme, as confirmed in ParkingEye v Beavis.
The Claimant has provided no explanation as to how the additional £70 was incurred.
Such sums are routinely disallowed by the courts because they represent an attempt at double recovery. In Excel Parking Services Ltd v Wilkinson (2020), the court held that similar additional recovery charges were not recoverable and constituted an abuse of process.
The Defendant therefore denies that the Claimant is entitled to recover the additional £70 or any interest calculated upon it.
PCN amount incorrectly stated
The signage at the location clearly states that the parking charge is £85. The Claimant, however, claims £90. The Defendant denies that any contract existed for £90, and the Claimant is put to strict proof of any signage displaying this amount.
The Defendant argues that the discrepancy in the PCN amount shows ambiguity in the contract terms.
The Defendant argues that this a breach of CPR 27 and inflates the claim.
Abuse of Process
The inflation of the claim by adding unrecoverable sums, and by claiming a principal amount higher than that displayed on the signage, is an abuse of process
The court is invited to strike out the claim on this basis.
Summary
The Defendant denies that any parking charge is owed.
The Claimant has failed to demonstrate:
driver liability,
lawful keeper liability under POFA,
a valid contractual breach, or
That the contract amount was £90
Entitlement to the additional £70,
Or that the validation system was functioning
Accordingly, the Defendant respectfully invites the court to strike out the claim as having no real prospect of success, or alternatively to dismiss it at trial.
#41
How can a WS include anything unrelated to the PoC?


Okay, so the PoC simply states 'liability as keeper' but does not limit that liability to purely that of PoFA - the Claimant will argue that the loose wording allows the pursuit of the keeper using any viable route.

Good spot on the date error in the WS exhibits - I missed that.

This remains an easy win in theory as the Claimant has not offered any evidence that the driver was acting as the company's agent at the material time - their entire case is purely theoretical in that respect - there is no substance.
#43
OP, we know your defence, it's been set out in their WS.

So:
PoC
Your defence based solely upon the PoC
Their WS which raises a completely new argument as 'employer' (I do not agree that the term 'registered keeper' in the PoC should have been inferred by the respondent as including 'employer' such that this could be addressed in their defence and WS.)


..so how can this be right
#44
OP, we know your defence, it's been set out in their WS.

So:
PoC
Your defence based solely upon the PoC
Their WS which raises a completely new argument as 'employer' (I do not agree that the term 'registered keeper' in the PoC should have been inferred by the respondent as including 'employer' such that this could be addressed in their defence and WS.)


..so how can this be right

So did I make a mistake in my defence allowing them to introduce a new argument?