31
Civil penalty charge notices (Councils, TFL and so on) / Re: Islington, Code 11 Parked without payment of the parking charge, Highbury Station Road
« on: November 06, 2025, 01:11:23 pm »
I think we're in danger of reading too much into that decision on the meaning of "match day".
While Carl Teper might not "have jurisdiction to strike down the Traffic Management Order as invalid, nor can I disregard a statutory definition on the basis of fairness or otherwise" he does have the ability (and duty) to determine if the signage accurately conveys the contents of the TMO to a diligent motorist, which it does not. If not, then we're in a ludicrous situation where councils can dispense with signage entirely.
I suspect he would have accepted this argument had appellant had brought it up, but didn't need to go there on this occasion because he'd already ruled in the appellant's favour.
While Carl Teper might not "have jurisdiction to strike down the Traffic Management Order as invalid, nor can I disregard a statutory definition on the basis of fairness or otherwise" he does have the ability (and duty) to determine if the signage accurately conveys the contents of the TMO to a diligent motorist, which it does not. If not, then we're in a ludicrous situation where councils can dispense with signage entirely.
I suspect he would have accepted this argument had appellant had brought it up, but didn't need to go there on this occasion because he'd already ruled in the appellant's favour.