Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - hellojeeves

Pages: [1]
1
Good news! They came back to my formal response to say they were cancelling the PCN! Presumably don't want the hassle of going to London Tribunals where they might actually make them fix the issue.

Thank you all for the help and advice.

2
Thank you! That makes complete sense. One point of clarification is that I did not pay a parking ticket as the paid parking bays are actually free during the time period I was there. It applies 10-13 and 14-16 Monday to Saturday and I was parked there at 13:41.

I have drafted a proposed response below, very grateful for any feedback or changes:

"I am writing to formally contest the parking Penalty Charge Notice (PCN) issued to me under reference number FR60945661 on November 24, 2023. I believe that the circumstances surrounding the issuance of this notice warrant a reevaluation, and I request that you reconsider the decision to uphold this PCN.
 
 I acknowledge that I was parked in a designated 'Permit Holders WSS only bay'; however, my decision to park was based on the information presented on the traffic sign nearby, which allows for paid parking. The sign indicated that a ticket was required between 10am-1pm and 2pm-4pm on the day in question. As it was between 1pm and 2pm when I parked there, I did not purchase a ticket. I fully complied with the displayed information and parked my vehicle during this legally acceptable period.
 
 Upon receiving the notice, I carefully reviewed the details provided by your authority. It has since come to my attention that the council has failed to maintain the crucial parking place dividing lines adequately, which demarcate the paid parking bays from the residents permit bays. The markings on the road have almost entirely faded, making it extremely difficult for drivers to discern the boundaries of the parking bays without prior awareness of its existence. This lack of maintenance is a crucial factor that should be considered in evaluating the validity of the issued notice.
 
 Moreover, I assert that the sign in question was misleading and did not conform to the recommended formatting outlined in the Traffic Signs Manual. The sign's placement, in proximity to my parked vehicle, naturally led me to believe that it applied to the adjacent bay. It was only after receiving the authority's response and scrutinising the markings under closer examination that I realised the sign applying to my bay was located much further down the road and away from my vehicle.
 
 I am confident that a fair and thorough examination of the circumstances will reveal that the combination of faded markings and the misleading sign wholly contributed to my parking in a Permit Holders WSS only bay. It is evident that the conditions at the time of the alleged offence were highly ambiguous and created confusion for drivers genuinely attempting to adhere to parking regulations.
 
 I am prepared to escalate this matter to London Tribunals if necessary, as I firmly believe that the failure to maintain the crucial parking place dividing lines and the deviation from best practices outlined in the Traffic Signs Manual are serious issues that warrant reconsideration.
 
 I kindly request that you review this representation with due diligence and take the aforementioned factors into account when determining the validity of the PCN. I trust that a fair assessment will result in the cancellation of the penalty.
 
 Thank you for your prompt attention to this matter. I look forward to a favourable resolution."

3
Additional photos are also viewable through https://walthamocm.itsvc.co.uk/PCN and by entering the above PCN number and reg

4
NTO

[ Guests cannot view attachments ]

5
@Hippocrates I don't have a record of the original challenge unfortunately as it was via web form and you don't get a copy. I should have saved it sorry. I've attached the full NTO and their response to the challenge. I also don't have the original PCN sorry it appears my partner dumped it.

Will add NTO in next post

[ Guests cannot view attachments ]

6
Just bumping this in case @Incandescent or anyone else has the opportunity to advise :) thank you!

7
Hello all - my NTO has come in. I have attached the cover page (notice date is 04/01/2024) and the page detailing possible grounds of representations. Grateful for any advice in pulling together a response on this given the earlier information within the thread. Thank you!

[ Guests cannot view attachments ]

8
Thank you both. I am going to appeal. I will update for advice once the NTO had come through in the coming weeks.

9
Got my own pictures today. Clearly highly faded but just about visible. Do I have a case here do we think? I genuinely didn't see these when I parked and it even took me a while to find when I knew where it was ;D

[ Guests cannot view attachments ]

10
Thanks so much! Looking at the old Google street image I realise I can just about barely make the lines out on the PCN photo provided. It is extremely faded, but just about visible, I genuinely did not see it and when I returned to look again I still could not see it. Will try to get my own pictures as I think these actually make it out to be better than it actually is. Do you think there is still a case if they are just barely visible like this?

[ Guests cannot view attachments ]

11
Hi all,

Penalty Charge Notice (PCN) Number: FR60945661
Vehicle Registration Number: BW67JFZ

I recently received a parking PCN for parking without a valid permit on Barrett Road in Walthamstow. On this street, there is an area with paid parking and an area with permit parking. I would have been legally parked in the paid parking area at the time of the incident, however the council are claiming I was in a permit area. There is no clear road marking to mark where the paid parking ends and the permit begins other than roadside signs several meters apart, one for permit parking and one for paid parking. As shown in the picture I was about 1m away from the paid parking sign and about 2m away from the permit sign. I have visited the street since and am still genuinely unsure where it actually transitions from one to the other.

The first attached image shows where my car was parked (with the paid parking sign on right and the permit sign on left). The second image is taken from the position of the paid parking sign and shows there are no road markings to show where the permit parking begins.

I made an informal representation which was rejected on the following grounds:

"According to the Civil Enforcement Officer’s (CEO`s) notes the vehicle was issued with the
PCN for being parked without displaying a valid Permit in a Permit Parking Bay.
I have carefully considered your case; however, the circumstances outlined in your
correspondence are not sufficient grounds for cancellation of the PCN in question. It is the
motorist’s responsibility to be aware of the restrictions in force at any given location and time.
Please be advised, along with the white bay markings there is adequate signage displaying
the restrictions in place. If a motorist is unsure of the restrictions in place they should not
assume it is okay to park, safe and legal parking should be sought to avoid incurring any
PCNs.

It is the responsibility of the motorist to ensure that a Permit is properly completed as stated
in the instructions and is displayed properly and securely at the front of the vehicle’s
windscreen or on the inside of the kerbstone window so that all the details can be seen from
outside the vehicle.

A CEO would observe a vehicle in a Permit Parking Bay for a minimum period of five minutes
before issuing a PCN and in this case the Officer had observed the vehicle in question at
13:31 and issued the PCN at 13:41.

If a motorist is unable to park in accordance with the regulations then alternative safe and
legal parking should be sought and used. I am therefore satisfied that this PCN was issued
correctly and you remain liable for the charge."

I now need to decide if I want to wait until a Notice to Owner is issued and make a formal appeal or to just pay the fine. To me it seems unreasonable to expect people to know this was a permit area as there are no road markings or clear signage showing this.




[ Guests cannot view attachments ]

Pages: [1]