Skip to content

Lambeth PCN code 19 Fentiman Road

70 Views 6 Replies

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Lambeth PCN code 19 Fentiman Road
on:
#1
PCN
https://drive.google.com/file/d/15ByYob5IYiJfUA6dF9Raf4EOX3B0la17/view?usp=drivesdk
Back of PCN
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1_HdZ7fDwMqSbdBiMzPgige5cJbytft4d/view?usp=drivesdk
Their pic1
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1-F_UkyZXTVit9IultwL-rh5UskME-1Pg/view?usp=drivesdk
Their other pic
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Z9TrADzNleclPXi5Gg7_boihePCGX60x/view?usp=drivesdk
GSV;
https://maps.app.goo.gl/7UknMQtQ6wcd1hYY8?g_st=ac


I was parked in bay unloading tools for a job in the hallway of an adjacent property. Van side door was open. Almost immediately saw a CEO behind the van in the road. I told him I was unloading and he walked away. The next time I saw him he was putting the ticket on the windshield.
I am in both his pics, and obviously unloading in his first pic, but I may struggle to prove I was continuously unloading for the intervening time.
I am a Lambeth resident in a different zone to the one I parked in, hence the CEO issuing a code 19, instead of a code 12.

I know Hippocrates has a technical defence against Lambeth pcns, and would appreciate if he would consider adding this one to his ever growing list.

I was thinking about the signs on nearly all Lambeth parking bays saying "Permit holders only" along with zone identifiers.
Stamfordman has commented on this before
I recall winning a case I think on this road where the CB sign was easily confused with CR at a reasonable glance at night and because Lambeth does spell out other permit bays (disabled) but not business. I don't think Lambeth does its residents favours here.

I'm looking at the Traffic Signs Manual and it's not very clear on permit bay signing but it does say:

However, previously prescribed legends should be used where appropriate. These are:

a) “Permit holders only”

b) “Resident permit holders only”

c) “Business permit holders only”

d) “Doctor permit holders only”

e) “Card holders only”.

And;
This case (possibly the OP's) was lost yesterday. My view is the parking signs must include words 'business', 'resident' etc to be clear and it's a pity there is no consistency among adjudicators.
.....
And H C Anderson;
OP, we are trying to help and understand why the meanings of our questions might seem odd. But they're directed towards helping you and so far, I for one am confused.

If a motorist parks in a bay such as yours they should be issued with a code 16 higher level penalty because it's a permit holders only bay. But London councils often don't when dealing with their own resident permit holders because 16 has to carry the higher level penalty. Instead they use code 19(lower level) which is a derivative of 16 and its sister, code 12. This confuses the average motorist. If you're interested, here's the list: https://archive.londoncouncils.gov.uk/download/file/fid/28636

A PCN must state: e)the grounds on which the civil enforcement officer serving the notice believes that a penalty charge is payable;


According to your PCN, there's no way that the grounds can be reconciled against any list, schedule, regulation or guidance which I know.

Invalid permit? You either had one that was at one time valid for this parking place or not.  Are Lambeth taking liberties with the narrow definition of 'invalid' to include any resident permit holder who is parking in a bay reserved for other permits? This is not their prerogative, it's the Mayor of London's.

Electronic payment - ???
So is it worth appealing on wrong contravention? Should be 16?
Last Edit: September 23, 2026, 09:20:36 pm by Rob232
Re: Lambeth PCN code 19 Fentiman Road
Reply #3 on:
#4
The parking sign says permit KR and KSR. We've seen Lambeth issuing a lower level penalty code 19 before when it should be 12 or 16.

But loading is an exemption.
Re: Lambeth PCN code 19 Fentiman Road
Reply #4 on:
#5
This PCN was cancelled by Lambeth today after my informal reps. I can post my reps if it helps anyone.

Thanks
Re: Lambeth PCN code 19 Fentiman Road
Reply #6 on:
#7
This was my informal challenge (not reps, sorry);

"Dear Sir or Madam,
On-line challenge for LJ40656172
On the grounds of:
The contravention did not occur
Reason:
At the time I am supposed to have been in contravention, I was loading and unloading
Further explanation :
please see attached PDF
Yours faithfully
*********
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
On-line challenges and representations service. Page 1/1
1 / 2
I wish to challenge this PCN on the ground that the contravention did not occur. I arrived at ***
Fentiman Road at 10:57, parked in the bay directly outside and was in the process of unloading my
tools up the steps and into the hallway. I happened to see the CEO on the road behind my van and told him I was unloading. He seemed to accept this, although he didn’t say anything, and walked
away up the road in the direction of the Fentiman Arms. I continued to unload my tools. About 5 minutes later I saw him placing the PCN on my windscreen. I asked him whether he had observed
me unloading and he said he had and walked away. At no time did he walk on the pavement
between the property and my van (with the side door open), presumably preferring to prepare the
PCN behind my van in the road. In the CEO’s first picture, I can be seen unloading, I am also in the
second picture asking him about his observation. As loading/unloading is an exemption to the
contravention cited, can you please cancel the PCN.

I also wish to challenge this PCN on the ground that there was a procedural impropriety on behalf
of the enforcement authority. The evidence provided by the CEO does not show any signage for the bay I was parked in. If the two photos on the website are the only two he took, then it is plainly not enough to show that a contravention occurred. Especially if the process reached NtO stage, and the owner was not the driver, how would the owner know what restriction was in force if none are in evidence? The council have a duty to act fairly, and the CEO should show why he thinks a
contravention has occurred. The PCN should be cancelled for these reasons.

I also wish to challenge this PCN on the same ground that the contravention did not occur in that
the wrong code was used on the PCN. As a resident of Lambeth, albeit in Stockwell, I have noticed
the almost exclusive use of “Permit holders only” signs for all types of parking bays. Looking at
London Councils PCN codes, only the code 16 would be relevant to a Permit contravention “Parked in a permit space or zone without a valid virtual permit or clearly displaying a valid physical permit where required”. The code 19 on the PCN, and its sister code 12, are only applicable to residents’ permit holders or shared use parking spaces, which a “Permit holders only” bay clearly isn’t., because it doesn’t have the word Resident on the sign. The code 19 could never be used in such a
bay, therefore the PCN should be cancelled.

I also wish to challenge this PCN on the ground that there was a procedural impropriety on behalf
of the enforcement authority. The wording in the code 19 is “Parked in a residents' or shared use
parking place or zone with an invalid virtual permit or displaying an invalid physical permit or
voucher or pay and display ticket, or after the expiry of paid for time”. Lambeth have taken the
word “invalid” to mean valid for another zone in Lambeth, however the meaning of invalid is quite
clear in this context, a permit was once valid for the parking space, but has since ceased to be valid.
A permit for another zone was never valid, therefore Lambeth should not have used code 19, and the PCN should be cancelled."

And this is their reply;

"Thank you for writing to us regarding the Penalty Charge Notice (PCN).
Following a review of the PCN, I have decided to cancel the notice on this occasion as benefit of doubt.
As a result, no payment is due, and the case is now closed.
Please be advised that any future PCNs issued under similar circumstances may not be cancelled.
Please also note that contravention code 19 can be used for Resident only bays, if the vehicle for example holds a permit
but for another zone.
If you require further information about this PCN, you may wish to visit our website at www.lambeth.gov.uk/parking.
For more details regarding how we use your personal information please view our Privacy Notice at
www.lambeth.gov.uk/parking-transport-and-streets
Yours sincerely
Lambeth Parking Services"

So not clear why they cancelled, could be no evidence of a sign (Southwark recently cancelled another PCN of mine where no signage photo was taken and they said not enough evidence iirc), they were wrong in putting up 'permit holders only' signs all over the borough, they didn't want to test their assertion in their reply that 19 was correct, loading actually happened or that they have partaken of the Xmas spirit early. Who knows?
Thanks Incandescent, good to see you still more than a bit peeved with the lot of them 😁
Last Edit: November 04, 2026, 05:00:55 pm by Rob232