Skip to content

Lambeth PCN 52M re Upper Ground

230 Views 25 Replies

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Lambeth PCN 52M re Upper Ground
on:
#1
Hello Moderators,

Lambeth issued a camera driven PCN for a 52M alleged contravention on Upper Ground. 
This is the same stretch  & similar scenario as in Case 2250600758 that Hippocrates helped to have dismissed at Tribunal level.

We initially thought we may have to pay up, but realised that details are the same as in above case, so forwarded our challenge - which was rejected. 

We hope to obtain more photos of the lack of advance warning of the problems at this junction, but initial challenge highlighting the discrepancy on their Payment portal was not accepted, and documents to appeal to the Tribunal have now been issued.

We will certainly forward an Appeal, but can a different judge take a varied view of the same circumstances?

Any advice would be much appreciated.
Thank you

Re: Lambeth PCN 52M re Upper Ground
Reply #1 on:
#2
As this appears to be a live case, the thread is moving. Please post up the paperwork to and from the Council in the usual way -only redact yr name & address - leave all else in.
Re: Lambeth PCN 52M re Upper Ground
Reply #3 on:
#4
Adjudicators are not bound to accept previous decisions of other adjudicators for a similar case,  but can be persuaded by presenting them as identical or very similar to the circumstances that are under notice.
Re: Lambeth PCN 52M re Upper Ground
Reply #5 on:
#6
We hope to obtain more photos of the lack of advance warning of the problems at this junction, but initial challenge highlighting the discrepancy on their Payment portal was not accepted, and documents to appeal to the Tribunal have now been issued.

We will certainly forward an Appeal, but can a different judge take a varied view of the same circumstances?



You have a Notice of Rejection, therefore you either pay or appeal.

Before we can advise, I refer to John U.K's post: we need paperwork, not more questions.
Re: Lambeth PCN 52M re Upper Ground
Reply #7 on:
#8
Please check their website payment status. If you stay with me the whole distance, they mess up big time at present.
@ALL MEMBERS

I HAVE A HIGH COURT CASE RE JUDICIAL REVIEW BUT WILL DO MY BEST TO ADVISE AND TAKE ON CASES IF AT ALL POSSIBLE.

If you do not challenge, you join "The Mugged Club".

cp8759 and mrmustard are true geniuses. I know my place in the hierarchy of The Three Musketeers. 😊 "The Clinician", "The Gentleman" and "The Showman"

There are "known knowns" which we may never have wished to know. This applies to them. But in the field the idea that there are also "unknown unknowns" doesn't apply as they hide in the aleatoric lottery. I know this is true and need to be prepared knowing the "unknown unknowns" may well apply.

To Socrates from "Hippocrates"
Re: Lambeth PCN 52M re Upper Ground
Reply #8 on:
#9
Hello  Hippocrates

At present, the Lambeth payment section cannot be accessed as it comes up with a large notice saying "We are carrying out maintenance", and there is no way to get onto the payment portal. 

I'm posting images of the PCN received & challenge forwarded.  (Please bear with me as I'm somewhat aged, & unsure if I'm going about it the correct way....!)

Hoping these links work:

https://ibb.co/ddSY4DS
https://ibb.co/qLHZhXpB
https://ibb.co/3mCxjvB5
https://ibb.co/1tzFx7yS
https://ibb.co/N6S7y5SW

More images to follow.....
Re: Lambeth PCN 52M re Upper Ground
Reply #11 on:
#12
As you have received a Notice of Rejection, we need this pl so that we can check for procedural correctness.
Re: Lambeth PCN 52M re Upper Ground
Reply #12 on:
#13

Apologies, Tincombe, something I'm doing is incorrect, I think,  as the images are not getting through. 

I have to get someone to help - which unfortunately for me - would not be today.

Shall get back here with the images as soon as I can.

In the meantime, thank you.
Re: Lambeth PCN 52M re Upper Ground
Reply #14 on:
#15
We drove this length of road in the weekend, and find there are no warning signs that would clearly inform motorists of restrictions within a very short length of road when exiting the National Theatre car park.

The reflective signs they refer to in their rejection letter,  certainly do not reflect even when car headlights are directed to them.