Author Topic: Islington PCN 01 Parking in a restricted street - St John's Way on single yellow line with no conventional sign  (Read 1156 times)

0 Members and 45 Guests are viewing this topic.

Hi, am wondering if anyone can help.

I parked at this location on a Saturday morning a few weeks ago:
https://maps.app.goo.gl/PARQS5mHycb5quZZA
(basically next to the red post box in case it's not clear where I was)

I was apparently in a restricted street, however I did not realise this at the time. I now know that there are signs at the entrance to the restricted zone, however I have never noticed them and they are a little way away and round the corner from where I actually parked.

There is no signage on the side of the road that I parked on (please see photo entitled "no signage"). In fact before leaving my car there, I walked the whole length of that section of St. John's Way, including the next block along (towards Archway corner), and found no sign at all.

The nearest sign, on the opposite side of the road says there is restricted parking between 7am and 7pm Monday to Friday (please see photo entitled "nearest signage"), so I assumed that this sign must apply to where I was parking, given this was the closest sign and in fact the only one in the near vicinity. NB this sign is not facing the right way, which is not helpful when people are driving along and need to see what the restrictions are.

I have parked in this location on a Saturday morning on a number of occasions previously and never been ticketed. On the date I got the ticket, there was another car also parked in front of me, so I assume they were also unaware of the restrictions.

I appealed the ticket on the above grounds and that I did not know I was in a restricted zone, but it was rejected on the basis that there were signs at the entrance to the zone. As mentioned I did not see these signs.

Can anyone please help? There is also a photo of the PCN front at the link below (apologies I am having trouble embedding the images in this post)

I'm extremely careful to park lawfully at all times as I can't afford to pay for tickets! So getting one and and having to pay £65 for making an honest mistake is particularly galling.

https://imgur.com/a/mersKxZ
« Last Edit: February 21, 2025, 01:55:59 am by Rosalind »

Share on Bluesky Share on Facebook


Let's see your challenge and their rejection.

What was your route into the zone.

Thank you for replying.

My challenge was similar to what I have written above, namely this:

"I was given a ticket for apparently parking in a restricted street during prescribed hours, however there is no signage stating this.

The side of the road where I parked has a yellow line, and there is no corresponding sign indicating the hours of this yellow line (please see attached photo entitled "no signage"). In fact before leaving my car there, I walked the whole length of that section of St. John's Way, including the next block along, and found no sign at all.

So to determine the parking restrictions, I looked to the nearest sign, which was just opposite, on the other side of the road.

This sign says there is restricted parking between 7am and 7pm Monday to Friday (please see attached photo entitled "nearest signage").

I assumed, as anyone would do, that this sign must apply to where I was parking, given this was the closest sign and in fact the only one in the near vicinity. NB this sign is not facing the right way, which is not helpful when people are driving along and need to see what the restrictions are.

As I parked on a Saturday morning and not between the restricted hours, I have therefore not parked unlawfully (I would never knowingly do so, as I cannot afford to pay expensive parking tickets).

I would be grateful if you would cancel this PCN as soon as possible."

And their response was this:

"We have considered the challenge you submitted and have found no grounds for
cancellation of the penalty charge.

The PCN was issued as your vehicle was parked in a restricted street during prescribed
hours.

Upon careful examination of the Civil Enforcement Officer's (CEO) notes, we can confirm
that the PCN was issued because the vehicle was parked in a controlled parking zone (CPZ)
without displaying a valid disabled badge or permit.

Controlled Parking Zones (CPZ) are areas where parking is restricted during certain hours,
typically indicated by signage. We understand your concern regarding the lack of signage on
the side of the road where you parked. However, the restricted area where your vehicle was
parked has clear regulations. According to the CEO notes, the CPZ on Papa Street, St.
John's Way, is in effect from 8:30 AM to 1:30 PM on Saturdays. This was the applicable time
at the moment the ticket was issued.

While you referenced the nearest sign on the opposite side of the road, this is not the
relevant signage for your parking location, as CPZ regulations are often specific to particular
sections of the street. Parking restrictions for each zone are governed by the signs closest to
where vehicles are parked, and in this case, the relevant restrictions apply directly to the
location where your vehicle was parked, not the sign on the opposite side.

It is important to note that controlled parking zones work by indicating the times and days
when parking is restricted. Signs are placed to ensure that drivers can easily understand
where and when restrictions apply. In this instance, the restricted hours for your parking area
were clearly indicated on nearby signs for the CPZ, and you were parked within those hours
without the necessary permit.

Considering the evidence available we are satisfied the contravention occurred and the PCN
was correctly issued. We are therefore upholding the PCN."


No idea where or what Papa Street is?
I did enter the CPZ via St John's Way, round the bend/curved bit of the road (I was travelling roughly Westwards towards Archway) but I honestly didn't see the signs.
« Last Edit: February 21, 2025, 12:41:03 am by Rosalind »

Well it would help greatly if you had the correct council on your heading !! It is an Islington not a Haringey PCN.

OK, so here are the zone entrance signs "just round the corner". They are just under 60 metres away : -
https://maps.app.goo.gl/9hrc9D4Y22yEvmWCA
These are Controlled Parking Zone (CPZ) entry signs.

A CPZ is a zone within which the restriction times for single-yellow lines are on the entry signs, not by each and every single-yellow sign in the zone. So essentially it is a cost saving device because no signs are needed at the single-yellow lines within the zone. A motorist must note the days and times on the sign if he intends to park within the zone on a single yellow line. Double-yellow signs apply 24x7 and need no signs. 

Where a different single-yellow line restriction is needed inside the zone, then this must have signs by the yellow line concerned. In your case the sign opposite where you parked is by a bus lane, so a sign has been applied for that as it is more restrictive than the overall CPZ restrictions.
https://maps.app.goo.gl/6hxHPXj7zxDkNGbr9
However, you seem not to be aware that being on the opposite side of the street it doesn't apply to the side where you parked.

What puzzles me is you saying "I now know that there are signs at the entrance to the restricted zone, however I have never noticed them and they are a little way away and round the corner from where I actually parked." But surely you would have passed them on your way to park ?

CPZ signs and their zones are all over London so I am surprised you seem not to know what they mean.  The Golden Rule in London when parking on single-yellow lines is never to assume anything. If there is no sign, it is highly likely you are parked within a CPZ and need to know the times on the sign.

Here is the Islington CPZ map, and shows that you parked in CPZ 'P'
www.islington.gov.uk/~/media/sharepoint-lists/public-records/transportandinfrastructure/information/maps/20192020/20190501cpzmap.pdf

Edit
Sorry the above is a bit too grumpy. I am suffering from rather severe sciatica, so apologise. However, I cannot see a win against the contravention itself, but London councils have been investing in software for acceptance of representations and some have made a complete boo-boo of it, such as to be a procedural impropriety in itself. So there may be a 'technical' appeal argument, but I'll pass this over to the experts.
« Last Edit: February 21, 2025, 01:15:43 am by Incandescent »

Oops, yes I had written the wrong borough in my subject heading and have now corrected it.

Because there was a sign on the opposite side of the road which listed a Monday to Friday restriction, I had simply assumed that it also applied to my side of the road - in my experience, every yellow line I've encountered usually has a sign next to it or very nearby, so I think I thought that the sign on my side was just missing for some reason. It didn't occur to me that instead there was a controlled parking zone in operation with different hours to the sign on the opposite side, and as mentioned, at the time I had no knowledge of the signs at the entrance to the CPZ.

I'm a Londoner and have been driving and parking in London for over 30 years, but I honestly didn't see the signs coming into the zone. Might be something to do with the fact that I was driving with my 5 and 8 year old in the back, who were undoubtedly fighting with each other at the time (and stressing me out).

But also, I'm very aware of those type of signs marking the entrance to residential parking zones, but have never really noticed them in relation to anything else i.e. yellow lines on main roads.

I'm slightly surprised that it's not a requirement for every yellow line to have its own sign (or for there to be one close by), but if that's the case, then I guess I don't have any grounds to get the PCN cancelled.

Thank you for your reply and your detailed thoughts about my predicament.
And I'm very sorry to hear about your severe sciatica. I've had sciatica a few times - the worst was when I had it quite badly and it lasted for about 7 months, so I completely sympathise.
« Last Edit: February 21, 2025, 01:59:19 am by Rosalind »

That other sign is clearly a mistake and while they are correct that you can't rely on it, it is misleading as in CPZs there can be yellow lines with their own timeplates but they are almost always for restrictions that are greater than the CPZ not less.

What was your route?

 

Thank you so much for taking the time to reply. I entered that parking zone travelling along St John's Way in a roughly Westerly direction, heading towards Archway corner.

I would have passed these signs that Incandescent has very kindly linked to below:
https://maps.app.goo.gl/9hrc9D4Y22yEvmWCA

Do you think I have any grounds for further appeal because of the misleading sign on the other side of the road? I'm guessing not!

Quote
Do you think I have any grounds for further appeal because of the misleading sign on the other side of the road? I'm guessing not!
You guessed correct !

However, it may not yet be game over, because fatal errors have been found in various London council web pages that show the details of a PCN, and entry of representations against it. Hippocrates is the "expert" in this one, with several wins now in his favour, so wait a bit to see what he says.

Will do. Thank you for your reply, it's much appreciated.